Relational Safety
Defensiveness and its correlation to relational safety – that is, the emotional and physical safety we experience (or lack thereof) within our interpersonal relationships – is something that fascinates me. Defensiveness can come about for a variety of reasons, but something I believe to be pretty universally true is that we are less defensive when our nervous systems don’t feel threatened.
When we know a relationship is safe, when we neurocept safety, we can land in proximity to someone else. Neuroception is an automatic, subconscious process by which our nervous systems scan our internal and external environments for cues of safety and danger. This happens long before our conscious thoughts, choices, and reasoning take over. By the time we are able to mobilize into a motor response – a movement, a thought, a sentence – our brains have already, at a very innate level, begun to determine whether or not we are safe.
The even more complex part? When people are scanning for danger, that danger is often not related to immediate physical harm or imminent threat, but rather to subtle relational dynamics that can feel like high-stakes interpersonal experiences. The possibility of someone important rejecting or criticizing you might consciously register as a frustrating experience, but at an attachment and neurobiological level, it can feel like severe danger. Danger of being cut off from connection. And when we are born, we NEED connection for survival. We come into this world fully dependent on others, for years, in order to survive. So the threat of loss in a relationship is, at an innate level, life-threatening, even as adults.
When we understand this context, it makes sense that when someone does not feel safe, they may behave in a variety of ways to cope with their terror and uncertainty. Defensiveness is one of those ways. Rather than feel the pain of shame when someone says something that really stings, we might lash out, deflect, or overprotect ourselves. Defensiveness is a psychological and behavioral reaction in which a person protects their ego, self-esteem, or sense of self-worth from perceived threats, criticism, or blame. Instead of listening or taking responsibility, a defensive person deflects the issue by making excuses, counterattacking, or shifting the blame. They may shut down and minimize another person’s experience in order to protect their preferred way of viewing themselves.
So, what is the relationship between defensiveness and neurocepting emotional safety? The more we sense that we are safe in our connection with others who matter to us, generally, our defensiveness decreases. Because we know this person is safe. And when someone is safe, there is room for both error and repair. There’s room to say, “I got it wrong, I hurt you, and I’m sorry.” There’s room to say, “I said one thing and did another. That’s on me. I’m sorry.” The apologies flow, the compassion is there, and there is a moving past the rupture.
We don’t do this work alone. We do it in relationships. And in relationships, we are messy and imperfect. But if we bring our humanity (and a healthy dose of humility) to our relationships, especially those closest to us, we can begin to create bonds with others in which accountability doesn’t feel like a threat, where repair becomes possible, and where being wrong doesn’t mean a loss of connection. Ultimately, the safer we feel with one another, the less energy we need to spend protecting ourselves, and the more room we have to listen, take responsibility, extend compassion, and stay connected – even when things get hard.